2016-2017: The Controversial Transition
MacBook Pro (2016-2017)
- Key Features:
- First-gen Butterfly Keyboard (prone to failure)
- Touch Bar (polarizing OLED strip)
- Thinner design, USB-C only
- Performance: Dual/Quad-core Intel CPUs, mediocre battery life
- 2024 Verdict:
Avoid due to keyboard issues and outdated Intel chips.
iMac (2017)
- Key Features:
- 5K Retina display (still gorgeous)
- 7th-gen Intel CPUs, Fusion Drives (slow by today’s standards)
- 2024 Verdict:
Only for light tasks; replace HDD with SSD.
2018-2019: Refinements, But Still Intel
MacBook Air (2018-2019)
- Key Features:
- Retina display, 2nd-gen Butterfly Keyboard (slightly improved)
- Dual-core Intel i5 (underpowered)
- 2024 Verdict:
Decent for basics if keyboard was replaced under warranty.
Mac mini (2018)
- Key Features:
- 6-core Intel i7 option, upgradable RAM
- T2 security chip
- 2024 Verdict:
Still usable for light server/desktop tasks.
2020: The Turning Point
MacBook Air (M1, Late 2020)
- Key Features:
- First Apple Silicon (M1) – revolutionary performance/battery
- Scissor Keyboard (fixed Butterfly issues)
- 2024 Verdict:
Still a great budget Mac (updates until ~2026).
MacBook Pro 13″ (M1, Late 2020)
- Key Features:
- M1 chip, 20-hour battery, Touch Bar retained
- 2024 Verdict:
Excellent for most users; avoid Intel 2020 models.
2021: Apple Silicon Matures
iMac 24″ (M1, 2021)
- Key Features:
- M1 chip, 4.5K Retina, colorful design
- No fan (silent operation)
- 2024 Verdict:
Great for home/office use but limited to 8GB RAM base.
MacBook Pro 14″/16″ (M1 Pro/Max, Late 2021)
- Key Features:
- M1 Pro/Max chips (10-core CPU, 32-core GPU options)
- MagSafe, HDMI, SD card slot (ports return!)
- 120Hz Mini-LED display
- 2024 Verdict:
Overkill for most, but future-proof for pros.
Should You Buy a 2016-2021 Mac in 2024?
Buy:
- M1 Macs (2020-2021) – Still powerful with years of support.
- M1 Pro/Max MacBook Pros – Beastly performance.
Caution:
- Intel Macs (2016-2019) – Only if dirt-cheap and for light use.
Avoid:
- Butterfly Keyboard Macs – Reliability nightmare.
Price Guide (Used, 2024)
- M1 MacBook Air: 500−700
- M1 Pro 14″ MacBook Pro: 1,000−1,400
- Intel Macs: Under $400 (only if desperate).